Loading blog content, please wait...
By Nashville Indiana Title Company
Two Types of Deeds and When Each One Fits TL;DR: A warranty deed and a quitclaim deed both transfer property ownership in Indiana, but they offer very d...
TL;DR: A warranty deed and a quitclaim deed both transfer property ownership in Indiana, but they offer very different levels of protection. Knowing which one you're signing — and why — helps you feel confident about your purchase or transfer.
Every property transfer in Indiana uses a deed. That part's simple. Where it gets interesting is the kind of deed involved, because the two most common types do the same basic thing in very different ways.
A warranty deed says: "I'm transferring this property to you, and I guarantee that I actually own it, that nobody else has a claim to it, and that there are no hidden surprises attached to it."
A quitclaim deed says: "Whatever ownership interest I may have in this property, I'm handing it over to you. But I'm not making any promises about what that interest actually is."
Same result on paper — your name goes on the property. But the level of protection behind that transfer couldn't be more different.
A warranty deed shows up in most traditional home purchases. If you're buying a house in Nashville this spring — maybe a cottage near downtown or a wooded retreat closer to Brown County State Park — you'll almost certainly receive a warranty deed from the seller.
This deed comes with what the legal world calls "covenants." In plain English, the seller is making you a set of promises:
If any of those promises turn out to be broken down the road, the seller is on the hook. That's powerful protection for a buyer, and it's exactly why warranty deeds are standard in purchase transactions.
Your lender will require a warranty deed. They're putting up a significant amount of money, and they want to know the property's ownership history has been thoroughly vetted. That vetting is part of what happens during a title search before your closing.
Quitclaim deeds pop up in situations where the people involved already know and trust each other. A few common scenarios:
Notice the pattern. These aren't arm's-length transactions between strangers. The people involved aren't negotiating a sale price or shopping for a mortgage. They're reshuffling ownership among people who already have a relationship.
In Brown County, where properties have sometimes been in the same family across generations, quitclaim deeds come up regularly. A grandparent's homestead, a parcel of wooded acreage outside Helmsburg, a cabin near Bean Blossom — these properties often move between relatives, and a quitclaim deed handles the transfer simply.
A warranty deed is like buying a car from a dealership with a full vehicle history report and a guarantee that it runs. A quitclaim deed is like your cousin handing you the keys and saying, "It's yours now."
Your cousin isn't lying. They genuinely believe the car is theirs to give. But if it turns out there's a lien on it, or someone else is on the title, that's your situation to sort out — not theirs.
With a quitclaim deed, the person signing it could technically have zero ownership interest in the property. The deed would still be a valid legal document. It just wouldn't transfer anything meaningful.
This is exactly why you'd never want a quitclaim deed in a standard purchase. If you're paying for a home, you deserve the full promise that comes with a warranty deed.
Once signed and notarized, both deed types get recorded with your county recorder's office. Here in Brown County, that's the Brown County Recorder. Recording makes the transfer part of the public record, which is how the world knows you own that property.
The Indiana Secretary of State's office oversees many of the state's recording standards, though each county handles its own filings. We work with the Brown County Recorder regularly and make sure your deed is prepared correctly and recorded properly.
If you're purchasing a home this spring — whether it's your first place or your forever home in Brown County — a warranty deed is what you want, and it's what you'll get through a standard closing.
If you're transferring property between family members or handling an estate situation, a quitclaim deed might be the right tool. It's simpler, faster, and works beautifully when trust already exists between the parties.
Either way, the deed needs to be prepared correctly, signed properly, and recorded with the county. That's where we come in. We handle both types regularly, and we're always happy to walk you through which one fits your situation — in plain English, over a cup of coffee if you'd like.