Loading blog content, please wait...
By Nashville Indiana Title Company
The Old Survey in Your Closing File Might Not Match the Fence The fence line runs along a row of cedars, right where it always has, and the survey in yo...
The fence line runs along a row of cedars, right where it always has, and the survey in your closing folder shows a neat rectangle that stops three feet short of them. You bought a wooded place off a gravel road near Bean Blossom, the survey came out of a stack of documents at closing, and now you're standing in your own side yard wondering which line is real. This happens more than people expect out here, and it is almost never a problem. It is usually just history.
Fences in Brown County get built for reasons that have nothing to do with property lines. Somebody put posts where the ground was flat enough to dig. Somebody ran wire around a garden or a paddock and never meant it to mark a boundary. A previous owner and a neighbor agreed, sometime back in the 1970s, that the fence would follow the tree line because that was easier than clearing brush along the true line.
Surveys, meanwhile, describe the legal boundary. On rural acreage the legal description might reference a monument that has moved, a creek bed that shifted after a hard spring, or an iron pin driven decades ago that has since been buried under leaf litter and root growth. When the survey in your file was done ten or twenty years ago, it captured the property as of that day. Trees grow. Erosion happens. Fences sag and get rebuilt a foot over from where they stood. So an old survey and a current fence disagreeing is not a contradiction. It is two different things measured at two different times for two different purposes.
A lot of buyers assume the survey in their closing packet is the current truth of the ground. It is really a photograph of one moment. Indiana does not require a brand new survey for every residential closing, so the document in your file may have been prepared for a refinance or an earlier sale years back. It was accurate then. That does not mean the fence, the driveway, or the shed built after it will line up with it now.
This is exactly why we look closely at survey documents during property document preparation rather than just sliding them into the stack. When we pull together the paperwork for a Brown County closing, part of what we are doing is reading the survey against the deed's legal description and against anything the title search turns up. If the survey shows an easement for the shared drive, we want that reflected. If a neighbor's fence appears to sit inside the described boundary, we want you to know that before you sign, not after you've hung a hammock on the wrong side of it.
The word encroachment sounds heavier than the reality usually is. It just means something is on one side of the line that the paperwork puts on the other side. A fence three feet in. A garden shed whose corner clips the neighbor's parcel. A gravel drive that curves across a boundary because that was the only sensible place to lay it on a hillside.
On the wooded lots and rolling acreage around Nashville, these show up regularly, and most of them have been sitting quietly for years with everyone content. The question at closing is not "who's right." The question is whether the arrangement is documented, whether anyone's rights are at risk, and whether your title insurance policy accounts for it. An owner's title policy can be affected by boundary matters, which is one more reason to understand what your survey shows and what it doesn't. If you want the plain-English version of what a title policy covers and where surveys fit in, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau keeps a helpful explainer on owner's title insurance.
Walk the property before closing, survey in hand. You do not need to be a surveyor. You are just looking for the obvious stuff: fences, sheds, the driveway, a well head, a septic field, anything a neighbor uses that crosses onto your parcel or the other way around. Note what doesn't seem to match and bring it to us. We would far rather sort out a question about a cedar row before the closing table than have you discover it a season later.
If the mismatch matters, there are clean ways to handle it. Sometimes it's a boundary line agreement recorded with the Brown County Recorder's office so the arrangement is official and travels with the property. Sometimes it's a new survey ordered so everyone is working from current ground truth. Sometimes it's a note in your policy. And sometimes the honest answer is that the fence is just a fence, the line is where the deed says, and nothing needs to change except your peace of mind. Part of our job during document preparation is telling you which of those it is.
Buying rural property here is genuinely different from buying a subdivision home in Indianapolis where the lots were platted all at once and the corners are marked with fresh pins. Out here the parcels were carved up over generations. A description might lean on a stone, a stake, or the centerline of a creek that has a mind of its own. That is not messy. That is just Brown County, and reading these documents carefully is exactly what we do.
So if you open your closing file and the drawing doesn't square with the fence you can see from your porch, don't let it rattle you. Bring it to us. Nine times out of ten it's a story we've seen before, and getting it right on paper before you sign is the whole point of doing the document work carefully in the first place.